Articles | Volume 32, issue 3
Eur. J. Mineral., 32, 355–365, 2020
Eur. J. Mineral., 32, 355–365, 2020

Research article 17 Jun 2020

Research article | 17 Jun 2020

Laurentthomasite, Mg2K(Be2Al)Si12O30: a new milarite-group-type member from the Ihorombe region, Fianarantsoa Province, Madagascar

Laurentthomasite, Mg2K(Be2Al)Si12O30: a new milarite-group-type member from the Ihorombe region, Fianarantsoa Province, Madagascar
Cristiano Ferraris1, Isabella Pignatelli2, Fernando Cámara3, Giancarlo Parodi1, Sylvain Pont1, Martin Schreyer4, and Fengxia Wei5 Cristiano Ferraris et al.
  • 1Institut de Minéralogie, de Physique des Matériaux et de Cosmochimie, UMR 7590, Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, CP 52, 61 rue Buffon, 75005 Paris, France
  • 2Laboratoire GeoRessources, Université de Lorraine, Faculté des Sciences et Technologies, Rue Jacques Callot, BP 70239, 54506 Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy, France
  • 3Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra “A. Desio”, Università degli Studi di Milano, Via Mangiagalli, 34 – 20133 Milan, Italy
  • 4Malvern Panalytical B.V., Lelyweg 1 (7602 EA), P.O. Box 13, 7600 AA Almelo, the Netherlands
  • 5Institute of Materials Research and Engineering (IMRE), 2 Fusionopolis Way, Innovis, #08-03, 138634 Singapore

Correspondence: Cristiano Ferraris (


Laurentthomasite, ideally Mg2K(Be2Al)Si12O30, is a new milarite-group member found within quartz-syenite pegmatites from the Ihorombe region, Fianarantsoa Province, Madagascar. It occurs as euhedral {0001} hexagonal crystals, maximum 15 mm large and 5 mm thick. The crystals show a very strong dichroism with cobalt blue and green-yellow colours when observed along [0001] and [1000], respectively. The mineral is transparent, uniaxial (+) and its lustre is vitreous. The hardness is about 6 (Mohs scale), showing a poor {0001} cleavage, irregular to conchoidal fracture, and a measured density of 2.67(8) g cm−3. Laurentthomasite is hexagonal, space group P6/mcc (no. 192), with a=9.95343(6) Å, c=14.15583(8) Å, V=1214.54(1) Å3 and Z=2. The strongest nine lines in the X-ray powder diffraction pattern [d in Å – (I) – hkl] are 3.171 – (10) – 211, 4.064 – (8) – 112, 2.732 – (8) – 204, 4.965 – (6) – 110, 2.732 – (4) – 204, 3.533 – (3) – 004, 7.055 – (2) – 002, 4.302 – (2) – 200 and 3.675 – (2) – 202. Chemical analyses by electron microprobe and several spectroscopies (inductively coupled plasma, ICP; optical emission, OES; mass, MS; and Mössbauer) give the following empirical formula based on 30 anions per formula unit: (Mg0.86 Sc0.54 Fe0.352+ Mn0.26)=2.01(K0.89 Na0.05 Y0.02 Ca0.01 Ba0.01)=0.98[(Be2.35 Al0.50 Mg0.11 Fe0.033+)=2.99(Si11.90 Al0.10)O30]; the simplified formula is (Mg, Sc)2(K, Na)[(Be, Al, Mg)3(Si, Al)12O30]. The crystal structure was refined to an R index of 1.89 % based on 430 reflections with Io > 2σ(I) collected on a four-circle diffractometer with CuKα radiation. By comparison with the general formula of the milarite group, A2B2C[T(2)3T(1)12O30](H2O) x (0<x<n, with n<2 pfu, per formula unit), the laurentthomasite structure consists of a beryllo-alumino-silicate framework in which the T(1) site is occupied by Si and minor Al and forms [Si12O30] cages linked by the T(2) site mainly occupied by (Be + Al). The A and C sites occur in the interstices of the framework while the B site is vacant. The origin of the strong dichroism is related to a charge transfer process between Fe2+ and Fe3+ in octahedral A sites and tetrahedral T(2) sites, respectively.

1 Introduction

Besides economic reasons, Madagascar's pegmatites are amongst the best research fields for mineral collectors because of both the size and the aesthetic characteristics of many different mineral species. Although there are more than 370 valid mineral species from approximately 1000 different localities in Madagascar (Mindat, 2020a), including a relatively large number of new mineral species containing the light elements Li, Be or B (Table 1), no new species belonging to the milarite group have been described. Milarite and osumilite have been reported in the central and southern regions of Amoron'i Mania and Anosy (Pezzotta, 2005; Holder et al., 2018), but laurentthomasite, Mg2K(Be2Al)Si12O30, is the first mineral species belonging to the milarite group for which Madagascar is the type locality.

Table 1Approved mineral species containing Li, Be and/or B from Madagascar.

References are those of the “The New IMA List of Minerals” updated to March 2020, available on the website (, last access: 6 May 2020) of the Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification (CNMNC) of the International Mineralogical Association (IMA).

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Laurentthomasite Mg2K(Be2Al)Si12O30 is the anhydrous Mg-dominant analogue of milarite Ca2K(Be2Al)Si12O30 and was approved as a new mineral species in April 2019 by the Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification (CNMNC) of the International Mineralogical Association (IMA) (2018–157) as a member of the milarite group (9.CM.05 in the classification of Strunz and Nickel, 2001).

The general formula of minerals belonging to the milarite group (Forbes et al., 1972) is VIA2IXB2XIIC[IVT(2)3IVT(1)12O30](H2O)x with x=0-n (n<2 pfu – Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016a), with the following known site occupancies: A = Al, Fe3+, Sn4+, Mg, Zr, Fe2+, Ca, Na, Y or Sc; B=, Na, K or H2O; C=, Na, K or Ba; T(1) = Al or Si; and T(2) = Li, Be, B, Mg, Al, Si, Mn, Fe2+ or Zn. Milarite-group minerals are double-ring silicates having maximum topological symmetry corresponding to space group P6/mcc, although cation ordering may lead to lower symmetry.

Together with the recent description of aluminosugilite (Nagashima et al., 2020), laurentthomasite attests to, once more, the great compositional flexibility of the milarite structure type; at the present time 25 members belong to this group, with the number constantly increasing from 15 in 1991 (Hawthorne et al., 1991) up to 23 in 2016 (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016a).

Laurentthomasite captured our attention whilst analysing a set of gemstones coming from the south of Madagascar. Its dichroism going from deep blue to green yellow together with prismatic hexagonal crystals was a source of perplexity for collectors, since it could be confused with both corundum sapphire and/or cordierite, mineral species much more common in the Madagascan southern provinces. Both sapphire and cordierite were rejected based on hardness measurements: 6 vs. 7.5 and 9 (Mohs scale), respectively. On the other hand, the first results of chemical investigations showing the presence of elements such as Sc, K and Be stimulated our interest. Scandium-rich minerals are very rare: only 15 terrestrial mineral species have scandium as an important constituent, while another five are of extraterrestrial origin (Mindat, 2020b)

The name laurentthomasite honours Laurent Thomas, born 1971 in Tours (Centre-Val de Loire, France). He has been a very active geologist, prospector and mineral dealer since the early 1990s, especially for African areas such as Madagascar. He is the one who first brought to the public knowledge some new species from Madagascar such as pezzottaite from Mandrosonoro, as well as new localities such those of grandidierite from Tranomaro, euclase from Itasy and chrysoberyl from Tsitondroina (see Lefevre and Thomas, 1998; Forner et al., 2001). The new mineral species and its name were approved by the Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification, International Mineralogical Association (IMA 2018–157).

The laurentthomasite description is based on one holotype and two cotype specimens, which are deposited in the collections of the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle (MNHN) of Paris (France); catalogue numbers are MNHN_MIN_218.1_a for the holotype and MNHN_MIN_218.1_b and MNHN_MIN_218.1_c for cotypes.

2 Geological settings

The studied samples were collected by Laurent Thomas in the Ihorombe region (Fianarantsoa Province) at about 80 km north-east of the village of Betroka (231603′′ S, 460549′′ E), in southern Madagascar. The area is located in the north-eastern part of the Ranotsara shear zone in the Antananarivo block, one of the five tectonic units into which Madagascar is divided (Collins et al., 2000; Collins and Windley, 2002). The Antananarivo block consists of 2550–2500 Myr granitoids tectonically interlayered with granites, syenites and gabbros (Tucker et al., 1999; Kröner et al., 2000). The whole of the Antananarivo block was thermally and structurally reworked between ∼750 and 500 Myr (Collins and Windley, 2002), with pre-existing rocks being metamorphosed to granulite facies and with the development of gneissic fabrics. Magmatism at circa 550 Myr produced granitoids bodies metres to kilometres across that are characteristic of this tectonic unit. Laurentthomasite was found within a pegmatite (coeval with these granitoid bodies) in a series of biotite- and amphibole-rich gneisses as well as migmatites and a set of pyroxene-rich alkali syenites (Besairie, 1959; Tucker et al., 1999; Kröner et al., 2000).

Laurentthomasite is associated with orthoclase, massive quartz, rare pale green apatite crystals, phenakite, beryl, albite, magnetite, thortveitite and cheralite (Fig. 1): at the microscopic scale unknown phases (currently under investigation) containing different ratios of Nb, Ta and W are also present. Due to the extremely weathered conditions of the few outcrops, pegmatite samples containing laurentthomasite are rare and deeply weathered into laterite; so far only one crystal in a matrix has been found, whilst isolated specimens are more common.

Figure 1(a) Blue hexagonal crystal of laurentthomasite in partially weathered pegmatite mainly composed of quartz, orthoclase, phenakite and secondary apatite. (b) Enlargement of (a).


The genesis of the new mineral laurentthomasite is related to crystallization of Sc-enriched pegmatites like those occurring at the Tørdal pegmatite field in southern Norway (Steffenssen et al., 2019). In contrast to the Tørdal bodies, the Madagascan pegmatite where laurentthomasite was found does not have any garnet that could be a major host for scandium.

3 Appearance and physical properties

The sample material consists of tabular euhedral {0001} hexagonal crystals with maximum width and thickness values of 15 and 5 mm, respectively (Fig. 1a–b); all observed laurentthomasite crystals are characterized by dark micrometric inclusions of elongated crystals of an Fe2+-rich phase as confirmed by Mössbauer spectroscopy. Observed forms are {1010} and {0001}. Crystals show a very strong dichroism with cobalt blue and green-yellow colours when observed along [0001] and [1000], respectively (Fig. 2a–b). The origin of dichroism lies in the presence of the transition metal ions Fe2+ and Fe3+, located in octahedral A sites and tetrahedral T(2) sites, respectively, and inter-valence charge transfer between them. Twinning was not observed. The mineral has a light blue streak and is transparent and non-fluorescent. Its lustre is vitreous. The hardness is about 6 (Mohs scale) based on scratching tests, with poor cleavage parallel to {0001}. The tenacity is brittle with irregular to conchoidal fracture. Laurentthomasite has a measured density of 2.67(8) g cm−3 (hydrostatic balance) and a calculated density of 2.66(4) g cm−3 using the empirical formula.

Figure 2Images showing the strong dichroism of laurentthomasite crystals. Under white light, crystals are deep cobalt blue along [0001] and yellow-green perpendicular to [0001].


In our 23 µm thick thin section, the mineral is colourless and pleochroism is not visible; it is optically uniaxial (+), with ω=1.540(2) and ε=1.545(3) (λ=589 nm) measured by refractometry; and dispersion was not observed. The compatibility index (1 – KP/KC)=0.028 is rated as excellent (Mandarino, 1981).

4 Analytical methods

For elements heavier than carbon, wavelength-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (WDS) 40-point analyses were performed with an electron microprobe CAMECA SX100 (Service d'Analyse Microsonde Camparis – Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris), at an accelerating voltage of 15 kV, a probe current of 10 nÅ and a beam diameter of 5 µm. Analysed elements and standards were Si, Mg and Ca (diopside); Al and K (orthoclase); Sc (synthetic Sc2O3); Ti and Mn (pyrophanite); Fe (hematite); Zn (sphalerite); Ba (baryte); and Na (albite). The polished section of the analysed crystal was free of inclusions, at least to the depth reached by the electron beam. Both beryllium and trace elements (including rare earth elements, REEs) were analysed using about 0.1 g of powdered sample by inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES) and mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) at the SARM laboratory of CRPG-CNRS. The amount of Fe3+ within the structure was deduced from Mössbauer spectroscopy (Fig. 3). The miniaturized Mössbauer spectrometer (MIMOS II) developed by Klingelhöfer et al. (1996) at the LCPME laboratory (Université de Lorraine, France) was used to investigate the oxidation state of iron in laurentthomasite samples.

Figure 3Deconvoluted Mössbauer spectrum of laurentthomasite.


Raman spectra (Fig. 4) were obtained using a modified Princeton Instruments spectrometer at the IMPMC (Institut de minéralogie, de physique des matériaux et de cosmochimie, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, France). The instrument is synchronized with a nanosecond pulsed diode pumped solid state (DPSS) laser operating at 532 nm with a 1.5 ns duration for the pulse, a 10 to 2000 Hz repetition rate and up to 1 mJ output energy per pulse. The spectrometer was synchronized and optimized to collect the signal only during the laser pulse in order to minimize the luminescence background.

Figure 4Raman spectrum of laurentthomasite compared to those of milarite and osumilite.


Powder diffraction X-ray data were collected between 4 and 100 (CuKα1-2-circle θ-θ goniometer) using a Bragg-Brentano X'pert Pro MPD diffractometer at the IMPMC.

A single-crystal (39.6µm×28.7µm×16.9µm) was analysed using an X-ray diffraction four-circle Agilent SuperNova instrument at the Institute of Materials Research and Engineering of Singapore (CuKα radiation); the data were collected in the 2θ range 0.279 to 113.785 at 10 s exposure for each frame (0.029 width) and integrated by the software CrysAlisPro; empirical absorption correction was applied.

5 Results

5.1 Chemical analyses

Tables 2 and 3 show the chemical composition of laurentthomasite. The deconvoluted experimental Mössbauer spectrum shows the presence of two types of octahedral Fe2+: the blue and the green curves belong to the laurentthomasite and the inclusions mentioned above, respectively (Fig. 3). As shown in Table 4 the Fe2+ and Fe3+ relative contents of laurentthomasite are 92.0 % and 5.8 %, respectively. Thus, after normalizing to 100 %, Fe2+ constitutes 94 % of the Fe in laurentthomasite itself. The violet doublet represents the tetrahedral Fe3+ contained within laurentthomasite; the centre shifts (CS), quadrupole splitting (QS) and relative areas are reported in Table 4.

Table 2WDS and ICP-OES-MS chemical analyses of laurentthomasite.

Measured by ICP-MS; the analytical uncertainty for both Y and Be contents is < 5 %. The amount of Fe2O3 was calculated starting from analysed FeO and the results of Mössbauer spectroscopy.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Table 3Trace element contents of laurentthomasite.

n.d: not detected. D.L.: detection limit.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

In Fig. 4 the Raman spectrum of laurentthomasite is compared to those of milarite and osumilite (Lafuente et al., 2015). The spectra are very similar in having the most intense peak around 480 cm−1 and comparable to the known spectra of other milarite-group minerals like brannockite, chayesite, or poudretteite (Lafuente et al., 2015) or friedrichbeckeite, and almarudite (Lengauer et al., 2009). Differences in Raman shifts of individual bands are due to the chemical variations, bond geometries and bond strengths for different mineral species. Figure 4 clearly shows that the laurentthomasite spectrum shares more affinities with the osumilite than with milarite; the most pronounced difference between the three spectra is the splitting of bands around 280 cm−1, with an evident separation into two components with maxima at 263 and 288 cm−1 for laurentthomasite.

The empirical formula based on 30 anions pfu (per formula unit) is (Mg0.86 Sc0.54 Fe0.352+ Mn0.26)=2.01 (K0.89 Na0.05 Y0.02 Ca0.01 Ba0.01)=0.98 [(Be2.35 Al0.50 Mg0.11 Fe0.033+)=2.99 (Si11.90 Al0.10) O30]. The simplified formula is (Mg, Sc)2(K, Na)[(Be, Al, Mg)3(Si, Al)12O30], while the ideal formula is Mg2K(Be2 Al)Si12O30, requiring K2O 4.96, BeO 5.27, MgO 8.49, Al2O3 5.37 and SiO2 75.92 for a total of 100 wt. %.

5.2 Crystallographic data

The cell parameters obtained from Rietveld refinement of the X-ray powder diffraction data (HighScore suite program, Degen et al., 2014) (Fig. 5; Table 5) are a=9.95343(6) Å, c=14.15583(8) Å, V=1214.54(1) Å3 and Z=2. Parameters used for the Rietveld refinement were (a) the 0 shift fixed at 0, (b) the background modelled using a flat and a 1∕X background as well as five parameters of a Chebyshev function, (c) isotropic displacement parameters for each atomic positions, (d) atomic occupancies for the non-oxygen positions, (e) the peak shape modelled using a pseudo-Voigt function with Finger–Cox–Jephcoat (FCJ) asymmetry (Finger et al., 1994) rather than a fundamental parameter approach so the microstructural parameters like size and strain were not refined, and (f) the preferred orientation was not refined.

Figure 5Rietveld refinement of the X-ray powder diffraction pattern of laurentthomasite.


Table 4Parameters from fitting of the Mössbauer spectrum.

Incl: inclusions. Laur: laurentthomasite. CS: centre shift. QS: quadrupole splitting. RA: relative areas.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Table 5X-ray powder diffraction data for laurentthomasite.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Single crystal X-ray diffraction investigations show that laurentthomasite belongs to the hexagonal crystal system with space group P6/mcc (no. 192) and unit cell parameters a=9.95800(7) Å, c=14.114916(11) Å, V=1215.081(15) Å3 and Z=2 (Table 6). The structure of laurentthomasite was refined using SHELXL-2012 (Sheldrick, 2015) starting from the atom coordinates of oftedalite (Cooper et al., 2006). Scattering curves of fully ionized species were used at cation sites (Rossi et al., 1983; Hawthorne et al., 1995): for the T(1) site ionized Si was refined vs. neutral Si; according to information from chemical analyses and also the fact that Fe and Mn have very similar scattering factors, Fe2+ + Mn2+ (0.61 apfu, atoms per formula unit) was constrained to be equal to Sc3+ (0.54 apfu) and then refined versus Mg2+ at the A site. Neutral vs. ionized scattering curves were used at oxygen sites (Rossi et al., 1983; Hawthorne et al., 1995). The Fourier difference map did not reveal any maximum above 0.29 e Å3. Anisotropic full-matrix least-squares refinement on Fo2 yielded R1=1.89 % [430 reflections with Io>2σI] and Rall=1.89 % (431 reflections). Experimental details are reported in Table 6. Refined atom coordinates and equivalent isotropic displacement parameters are reported in Table 7. Selected interatomic distances and bond angles are given in Table 8. A Crystallographic Information File (CIF) and list of observed and calculated structure factors are available as electronic material. The structure is isotypic with minerals of the milarite group (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016a).

Table 6Crystal data and structure refinement for laurentthomasite.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Table 7Atomic coordinates, chemical site occupancies (occ.), electrons per site and isotropic displacement parameters Ueq for laurentthomasite. Wyck. stands for Wyckoff positions.

s.s. is site scattering, XRD is X-ray diffraction, EMP is electron microprobe and e.p.s. is electrons per site. The Al also accounts for Mg.

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

Table 8Bond lengths (Å) for laurentthomasite.

OAV: octahedral angle variance; OQE: octahedral quadratic elongation; TAV: tetrahedral angle variance; TQE: tetrahedral quadratic elongation, as defined in Robinson et al. (1971).

Download Print Version | Download XLSX

6 Discussion

As discussed by Gagné and Hawthorne (2016a), the structure of the milarite-group minerals is a beryllo-alumino-silicate framework consisting of a four-connected three-dimensional net.

The majority of the minerals belonging to the milarite group can be described with space-group symmetry P6/mcc (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016a), which is reduced to P62c and Pnc2 because of cation ordering in respectively roedderite and armenite (Armbruster, 1989, 1999).

The main feature of the laurentthomasite structure is a [T(1)12O30] unit consisting of double six-membered rings of corner-linked SiO4 tetrahedra (Fig. 6). These rings are stacked along the c axis, thus establishing a channel system along [0001]. These units are interconnected by sharing corners with T(2)O4 tetrahedra. These obtained structural blocks are arranged in groups of three around one centrally located AO6 octahedron. The C site is situated in the centre of the channel between two [T(1)12O30] units (Fig. 7).

Figure 6The double ring of T(1) tetrahedra, obtained with VESTA 3.0 (Momma and Izumi, 2011).


Figure 7The AT(2) layer forming 12 rings. These rings are aligned with six-membered double Si rings along [0001]. C sites are located at the centre of these channels. T(2) sites are shown in green; A sites are shown in pink. Diagram obtained with VESTA 3.0 (Momma and Izumi, 2011).


Laurentthomasite presents the charge arrangement [10] of Gagné and Hawthorne (2016b). It is related to oftedalite (ScCaKBe3Si12O30; Cooper et al., 2006) by the (AScT(2)Be)−1(AMgT(2)Al) and ACa-1AMg substitutions, to milarite (Ca2KBe2AlSi12O30) by the ACa-2AMg2 substitution, and to friedrichbeckeite (Mg2NaKBe3Si12O30; Lengauer et al., 2009) by the (BNaT(2)Be)−1(BT(2)Al) substitution.

Hawthorne et al. (1991) observed <T-O> distances of 1.609–1.612 Å for several milarite crystals with T(1)= (Si11.89-Si12): mean value of 1.611 Å. Anyway, the observed <T(1)–O > distance, 1.608(2) Å (Table 8), is compatible with the full occupancy of Si at the T(1) site, and it compares well, within experimental error, with the distances observed in other T(1)Si members of the milarite group, as for instance 1.609 Å in sugilite (Armbruster and Oberhänsli, 1988) or 1.610 Å in aluminosugilite (Nagashima et al., 2020). Therefore, even if the empirical formula of laurentthomasite shows Si = 11.90 apfu vs. Al = 0.10 apfu, the scattering curve of Al was not taken into account during refinement. The tetrahedral quadratic elongation value (TQE) (Table 8), as defined in Robinson et al. (1971), shows that the T(1) site is rather regular (7.392), whereas the T(2) sites is much more distorted [see the tetrahedral angle variance (TAV = 196.132)], in agreement with a mixed occupancy site.

The observed <T(2)–O > distance of 1.674(1) Å (Table 8) is slightly larger than the predicted value of 1.637 Å (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016b) for a pure [4]BeO bond length. As, according to the chemical analysis, the T(2) occupancy, besides the presence of Be2+ (2.35 apfu) and Al (0.50 apfu), also shows the presence of Mg (0.11 apfu) and a very small amount of Fe3+ determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy. Considering thus a [4]MgO of 1.939 Å (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016b), and the larger ionic radius of Al3+ with respect to Be2+, one can easily justify the slightly higher value (1.674 vs. 1.637 Å). The refined occupancy for Be is 0.74(1) atoms per site (i.e. 2.22 apfu) (Table 7), which is comparable to the one resulting from chemical analyses (2.35 apfu), and the refined occupancy of Al (inclusive of Mg and Fe), at T(2) of 0.26(1) (i.e. 0.78 apfu). The refined site scattering at T(2) is therefore 18.82 epfu (electrons per formula unit), and compared to the scattering calculated from chemistry (18.0 epfu), this indicates that, in the crystal studied by single crystal X-ray diffraction, Mg2+ at T(2) might be lower (or even [4]Fe3+ higher up to 0.06 apfu). Better agreement could be obtained with only Al and Be at T(2), although this is not supported by chemical analyses nor supported by the mean bond length at T(2). Allocation of 0.03 apfu Fe3+ at this site seems to be in agreement with the larger size observed. On the basis of the assumed mixed occupancy of T(2), the calculated value [using bond-distances from Shannon, 1976 and Gagnè and Hawthorne, 2016a] is 1.665 Å, in reasonable agreement with the observed value of 1.674 Å.

The refinement yields a C site fully occupied by K (19.1 epfu), in good agreement with the chemical analysis that shows 0.89 K + 0.05 Na + 0.02 Y + 0.01 Ca + 0.01 Ba = 0.98 apfu, corresponding to a calculated site scattering of 19.0 epfu. The <C–O > distance, 3.086(1) Å (Table 8), is in good agreement with the [12]K–O bond length (3.095 Å) predicted by Gagné and Hawthorne (2016b) of 3.095 Å, considering the presence of about 10 % smaller cations (Na, Ca and Ba).

The A site is a strongly distorted octahedron as shown by the octahedral angle variance (OAV = 166.92, Table 8); the observed <A–O > distance of 2.136(1) Å (Table 8) is slightly longer than predicted for a pure [6]Mg–O bond length (2.089 Å) (Gagné and Hawthorne, 2016b). Considering the A site population obtained by chemical analyses (A2+=1.47 apfu) and taking into account the quite significant presence of Sc (0.54 apfu), one could justify the derived longer value, given the [6]Sc–O bond length (2.121 Å: Cong et al., 2010; bixbyite-type Sc2O3). Nevertheless, the presence of 0.61 apfu of Fe2+ and Mn2+ (0.35 Fe2+0.26 Mn) also contributes to the lengthening of the <A–O > mean bond distance, in closer agreement with the observed value. However, this is not yet enough because the calculated mean bond length is 2.123(1) Å (using the ionic radii of Shannon, 1976) (Table 8). The A site is therefore larger than expected; this is probably due to (i) the A octahedron sharing three edges with three T(2) tetrahedra as well as to (b) an increased charge at the T(2) site due to some replacement of Be by Al (and minor Fe3+). All these features induce an increase of the A–O(3) bond distance. Incidentally, the refined ionization of O3 shows almost completely ionized oxygen at that site (92 %), compared with ionization refined at O1 and O2 sites (ca. 65 %, Table 7). This should be ascribed to the strong incidence of charge at the O3 site, which is threefold coordinated with one T(2) site, one T(1) site and one A site, whereas the O1 site is twofold bonded just to two Si4+ at the T(1) site, and the O2 site is threefold bonded to two Si4+ at the T(1) site and has a long bond to K+ at the C sites. It is therefore more plausible to have a more covalent bond at the O1 and O2 sites, in full agreement with refinement. The refined scattering (37.12 epfu – Table 7) of the A site is in very good agreement with the chemical analysis (37.2 epfu). The Fourier difference map clearly indicates that the B sites are vacant in laurentthomasite.

The milarite group has yet again demonstrated an extraordinary versatility in its crystal chemistry.

Data availability

The data used in this paper can be found in the Supplement.


The supplement related to this article is available online at:

Author contributions

CF and GCP designed the experiments. SP, IP and FW carried them out. FC and MS developed the model and performed the refinements. CF prepared the manuscript with contributions from all co-authors.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.


The authors wish to thank Mustapha Abdelmoula for the Mössbauer data and Olivier Beyssac for the Raman facilities. The authors would also like to thank Thomas Armbruster, Edward Grew, and an anonymous referee for their constructive criticism and fruitful suggestions that substantially helped to improve the quality of the manuscript, as well David Smith for revising both the grammar and English style of an earlier version of the manuscript.

Review statement

This paper was edited by Sergey Krivovichev and reviewed by Thomas Armbruster and one anonymous referee.


Armbruster, T.: Crystal chemistry of double-ring silicates: structure of roedderite at 100 and 300 K, Eur. J. Mineral, 1, 701–714, 1989. 

Armbruster, T.: Si, Al ordering in the double-ring silicate armenite, BaCa2Al6Si9O30 • 2H2O: A single-crystal X-ray and 29Si MAS NMR study, Am. Mineral., 84, 92–101, 1999. 

Armbruster, T. and Oberhänsli, R.: Crystal chemistry of double-ring silicates: Structures of sugilite and brannockite, Am. Mineral., 73, 595–600, 1988. 

Besairie, H.: Rapport annuel du Service Géologique de la République Malgache, 303 pp., 1959. 

Cempírek, J., Grew, E. S., Kampf, A. R., Ma, C., Novák, M., Gadas, P., Škoda, R., Vašinová-Galiová, M., Pezzotta, F., Groat, L. A., and Krivovichev, S.: Vránaite, ideally Al16B4Si4O38, a new mineral related to boralsilite, Al16B6Si2O37, from the Manjaka pegmatite, Sahatany Valley, Madagascar, Am. Mineral., 101, 2108–2117,, 2016. 

Collins, A. S. and Windley, B. F.: The tectonic evolution of central and northern Madagascar and its place in the final assembly of Gondwana, J. Geol., 110, 325–340, 2002.  

Collins, A. S., Windley, B. F., and Razakamanana, T.: Neoproterozoic extensional detachment in central Madagascar: implications for the collapse of the East African Orogen, Geol. Mag., 137, 39–51, 2000. 

Cong, H., Zhang, H., Yao, B., Yu, W., Zhao, X., Wang, J., and Zhang, G.: ScVO4: Explorations of novel crystalline inorganic optical materials in rare-earth orthovanadate systems, Cryst. Growth Des., 10, 4389–4400,, 2010. 

Cooper, M. A., Hawthorne, F. C., Ball, N. A., Černý, P., and Kristiansen, R.: Oftedalite, (Sc,Ca,Mn2+)2K(Be,Al)3Si12O30, a new member of the milarite group from the Heftetjern pegmatite, Tørdal, Norway: description and crystal structure, Can. Miner., 44, 943–949,, 2006. 

Degen, T., Sadki, M., Bron, E., König, U., and Nénert, G.: The High Score Suite, J. Powder Diff., 29–2, 13–18,, 2014. 

Demartin, F., Diella, V., Gramaccioli, C. M., and Pezzotta, F.: Schiavinatoite, (Nb,Ta)BO4, the Nb analogue of behierite, Eur. J. Mineral., 13, 159–165,, 2001. 

Dunn, P. J., Appleman, D. E., and Nelen, J. E.: Liddicoatite, a new calcium end-member of the tourmaline group, Am. Mineral., 62, 1121–1124, 1977. 

Finger, L. W., Cox, D. F., and Jephcoat, A. P.: A correction for powder diffraction peak asymmetry due to axial divergence, J. Appl. Crystallogr., 27, 892–900,, 1994. 

Fleischer, M.: New Mineral Names, Am. Mineral., 414, 14–420, 1962. 

Forbes, W. C., Baur, W. H., and Khan, A. A.: Crystal chemistry of milarite-type minerals, Am. Mineral., 57, 463–472, 1972. 

Forner, H., Gautier, F., and Thomas, L.: Les macles de quartz de la région d'Andilamena, Madagascar, Le Règne Minéral, 39, 42–46, 2001. 

Gagné, O. C. and Hawthorne, F. C.: Chemographic exploration of the milarite-type structure, Can. Mineral., 54, 1229–1247,, 2016a. 

Gagné, O. C. and Hawthorne, F. C.: Bond-length distributions for ions bonded to oxygen: alkali and alkaline-earth metals, Acta Crystallogr. B, B72, 602–625,, 2016b. 

Hawthorne, F. C., Kimata, M., Černý, P., Ball, N., Rossman, G. R., and Grice, J. D.: The crystal chemistry of the milarite-group minerals, Am. Mineral., 76, 1836–1856, 1991. 

Hawthorne, F. C., Ungaretti, L., and Oberti, R.: Site populations in minerals; terminology and presentation of results of crystal-structure refinement, Can. Mineral., 33, 907–911, 1995. 

Holder, R. M., Hacker, B. R., Horton, F., and Rakotondrazafy, A. F. M.: Ultrahigh-temperature osumilite gneisses in southern Madagascar record combined heat advection and high rates of radiogenic heat production in a long-lived high-T orogen, J. Metamorph. Geol., 36, 855–880,, 2018. 

Klingelhöfer, G., Fegley Jr., B., Morris, R. V., Kankeleit, E., Held, P., Elvanov, E., and Priloutskii, O.: Mineralogical analysis of Martian soil and rock by a miniaturized backscattering Mössbauer spectrometer, Planet Space Sci., 44, 1277–1288, 1996. 

Kröner, A., Hegner, E., Collins, A. S., Windley, B. F., Brewer, T. S., Razakamanana, T., and Pidgeon, R. T.: Age and magmatic history of the Antananarivo Block, central Madagascar as derived from zircon geochronology and Nd isotopic systematics, Am. J. Sci., 300, 251–288, 2000. 

Lacroix, A.: Note préliminaire sur une nouvelle espèce minérale, B. Soc. Fra. Mineral., 25, 85–86, 1902. 

Lacroix, A.: Sur une nouvelle espèce minérale (bityite) et sur les minéraux qu'elle accompagne dans les gisements tourmalinifères de Madagascar, Cr. Acad. Sci. Nat., 146, 1367–1371, 1908. 

Lacroix, A.: Sur une nouvelle espèce minérale (manandonite) des pegmatites de Madagascar, B. Soc. Fra. Mineral., 35, 223–226, 1912. 

Lafuente, B., Downs, R. T., Yang, H., and Stone, N.: The power of databases: the RRUFF project, in: Highlights in Mineralogical Crystallography, edited by: Armbruster, T. and Danisi, R. M., Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin, Germany, 1–30,, 2015. 

Laurs, B. M., Simmons, W. B., Rossman, G. R., Quinn, E. P., McClure, S. F., Peretti, A., Armbruster, T., Hawthorne, F. C., Falster, A. U., Günther, D., Cooper, M. A., and Grobéty, B.: Pezzottaite from Ambatovita, Madagascar: A New Gem Mineral, Gems Gemol., 39, 284–301, 2003. 

Lefevre, T. L. and Thomas, L.: Les pegmatites de la vallée de la Sahatany, Madagascar, Le Règne Minéral, 19, 15–28, 1998. 

Lengauer, C. L., Hrauda, N., Kolitsch, U., Krickl, R., and Tillmanns, E.: Friedrichbeckeite, K(0.5Na0.5)2(Mg0.8Mn0.1Fe0.1)2(Be0.6Mg0.4)3[Si12O30], a new milarite-type mineral from the Bellerberg volcano, Eifel area, Germany, Miner. Petrol., 96, 221–232,, 2009. 

Mandarino, J. A.: The Gladstone-Dale relationship. IV. The compatibility concept and its application, Can. Mineral., 41, 989–1002, 1981. 

Mindat: Mineral species of Madagascar, available at:, last access: 24 March 2020a. 

Mindat: Sc-rich mineral species, available at:, last access: 25 March 2020b. 

Momma, K. and Izumi, F.: VESTA 3 for three-dimensional visualization of crystal, volumetric and morphology data, J. Appl. Crystallogr., 44, 1272–1276,, 2011. 

Nagashima, M., Fukuda, C., Matsumoto, T., Imaoka, T., Odicino, G., and Armellino, G.: Aluminosugilite, KNa2Al2Li3Si12O30, an Al analogue of sugilite, from the Cerchiara mine, Liguria, Italy, Eur. J. Mineral., 32, 57–66,, 2020. 

Pezzotta, F.: La pegmatite di Ambatovita, un giacimento ricco di micro-minerali, Rivista Mineralogica Italiana, 30, 100–101, 2005. 

Robinson, K., Gibbs, G. V., and Ribbe, P. H.: Quadratic elongation: a quantitative measure of distortion in coordination polyhedra, Science, 172, 567–570, 1971. 

Rossi, G., Smith, D. C., Ungaretti, L., and Domeneghetti, M. C.: Crystal-chemistry and cation ordering in the system diopside-jadeite: A detailed study by crystal structure refinement, Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., 83, 247–258, 1983. 

Shannon, R. D.: Revised effective ionic radii and systematic studies of interatomic distances in halides and chalcogenides, Acta Crystallogr. A, 32, 751–767, 1976. 

Sheldrick, G. M.: Crystal Structure refinement with SHELX, Acta Crystallogr. C, 71, 3–8,, 2015. 

Simmons, W. B., Pezzotta, F., Falster, A. U., and Webber, K. L.: Londonite, a new mineral species: the Cs-dominant analogue of rhodizite from the Antandrokomby granitic pegmatite, Madagascar, Can. Mineral., 39, 747–755, 2001.  

Steffenssen, G., Müller, A., Rosing-Schow, N., and Friis, H.: The distribution and enrichment of scandium in garnets from the Tørdal pegmatites, south Norway, and its economic implications, Can. Mineral., 57, 799–801,, 2019. 

Strunz, H. and Nickel, E. H.: Strunz mineralogical tables. Schweizerbart, Stuttgart, 869 pp., 2001. 

Tucker, R. D., Ashwal, L. D., Handke, M. J., Hamilton, M. A., Le Grange, M., and Rambeloson, R. A.: U-Pb geochronology and isotope geochemistry of the Archean and Proterozoic rocks of north-central Madagascar, J. Geol., 107, 135–153, 1999. 

Short summary
Laurentthomasite is a new mineral from Madagascar showing a very strong dichroism going from deep blue to yellow-green colours. The physical and chemical characteristics of this gem quality mineral bring it to the attention of the jewel industry as well as collectors of cut stones.